Trading Up to Godlies: Upgrading Legendaries in Murder Mystery 2
Learn how Murder Mystery 2 traders can leverage vintage holiday legendaries to bridge the gap and upgrade into entry-level Godly weapons.

Trading up from lower-tier inventory into Godly weapons remains one of the toughest hurdles for newer Murder Mystery 2 players. A recent discussion in the trading community brought this challenge back into focus, as players look to bundle legendary collectibles—such as seasonal Halloween gun skins from 2018—alongside add-ons to secure entry-level Godlies valued between 10 and 20.
Breaking out of the legendary tier requires a solid grasp of market demand, item history, and realistic trade expectations. Here is how you can assess your vintage skins and bridge the gap to your very first Godly weapon.
Evaluating Vintage Legendaries Against Low-Tier Godlies
Many traders hold onto older holiday legendaries assuming their age automatically translates into a high-tier trade. While older event skins, like those from the 2018 Halloween event, carry nostalgia and niche appeal, their value often depends heavily on the specific item name and general collector interest.
Entry-level Godlies typically hover in the low value ranges (often around 10 to 20 or even single digits depending on the valuation list you use). Popular bottom-tier Godlies like Peppermint, Frostbite, Snowflake, or common vintage items serve as frequent targets for budget traders. However, owners of these weapons usually look for overpays if they are accepting downgrades into legendaries, because Godlies are inherently much easier to flip and trade away.
Why Godly Owners Hesitate on Legendary Bundles
When attempting to trade a single legendary plus random adds for a low-tier Godly, traders frequently hit a wall. Understanding the hesitation from the other side of the trade window can help you adjust your strategy:
Liquidity and Demand Differences
Even a low-tier, duplicate Godly retains baseline liquidity. Players can bundle two or three junk Godlies together to work toward mid-tier weapons. In contrast, random legendary skins often sit in inventories for weeks without serious offers, making most traders reluctant to trade down unless they specifically collect that cosmetic.
The Problem With 'Random Adds'
Offering filler skins or common cosmetics rarely moves the needle for an experienced trader. Quality almost always trumps quantity. If your adds consist of modern, unboxed craftables or common event drops, they add virtually zero perceived value to the deal.
Practical Steps to Upgrade Your Inventory
If you are trying to break into the Godly bracket using event legendaries, consider these practical adjustments:
- Identify the exact skin: Research the specific name of your seasonal skin on community tier lists. Some specific 2018 event items carry decent collector demand, while others remain common bulk items.
- Target collector servers: Standard trading lobbies usually prioritize shiny Godly knives and guns. Look for dedicated trading communities or collector lobbies where players actively seek out older holiday cosmetics to complete past sets.
- Flip legendaries into stacks first: Instead of offering one legendary and random junk, try trading small items upward into multiple recognized legendaries or out-of-game stacks. Offering three recognizable, desirable legendaries gives you far more leverage when chasing an entry-level Godly.
Trading up without spending Robux takes patience and realistic valuations, but targeting the right buyer for older holiday gear is the most reliable way to score that first upgrade.

