All Murder Mystery 2 articles
Murder Mystery 2

MM2 Trader Regrets "Ice Cream" Trade for Borealis, Citing Value Oversight

A Murder Mystery 2 trader recently shared their regret after trading away their "Borealis" item for "Ice Cream," believing the latter was still rising in value. This trade has sparked discussion among the community about the importance of checking current item values.

September 12, 2026 URV Editorial

A recent post on the r/MurderMystery2 subreddit highlighted a common pitfall in trading: relying on outdated information. A trader, user diarrheasexsmosh, expressed significant regret after exchanging their "Borealis" item for "Ice Cream." They admitted to assuming "Ice Cream" was still increasing in value without verifying current market trends, a decision that ultimately led to disappointment, especially as they found the "Ice Cream" item "super ugly" and Borealis was a prized possession.

This story is a stark reminder for all MM2 traders about the dynamic nature of in-game economies and the critical need for up-to-date knowledge.

The Trade in Question

The user traded their "Borealis" item, which they considered one of their best, for "Ice Cream." Their rationale was that "Ice Cream" had been on an upward trend, and they hoped to capitalize on its continued rise. However, the market had shifted, and their assumption proved incorrect. The immediate regret stemmed from the item's aesthetic, but the underlying issue was a misjudgment of its current trade value and demand.

Why Values Fluctuate

Item values in Murder Mystery 2, much like any player-driven economy, are constantly shifting. Several factors contribute to these changes:

  • Rarity: How difficult is the item to obtain?
  • Demand: How many players want this item? Popular items often hold higher value.
  • Supply: How many of this item are currently in circulation?
  • Aesthetics: While subjective, "looks" can impact demand. If an item is widely considered visually appealing, its demand might be higher.
  • Updates and Events: New releases or game events can sometimes indirectly affect the value of existing items by introducing new desirable items or changing player preferences.

In this particular case, it seems the "Ice Cream" item's perceived value no longer aligned with its actual market standing, leading to the trader's regret.

Practical Takeaways for MM2 Traders

This experience offers valuable lessons for everyone involved in Murder Mystery 2 trading. To avoid similar situations, consider these points:

Always Verify Current Values

Before making any significant trade, always double-check the most recent value lists and community discussions. Do not rely on memory or assumptions about an item's trajectory. Communities like Ultimate Roblox Values, Reddit forums, and various Discord servers dedicated to MM2 trading are excellent resources for real-time information.

Understand Demand and Aesthetics

While value lists provide a numerical guide, understanding demand is equally crucial. An item might have a certain listed value, but if nobody wants it, it can be hard to trade. Furthermore, if you're trading for an item you don't personally like the look of, ensure its trade value genuinely makes up for that lack of personal appeal. Trading for items you find aesthetically displeasing purely for assumed profit can lead to "trader's remorse," as seen here.

Don't Be Afraid to Say No

If a trade doesn't feel right, or if you're unsure about the value of an item, it's always better to decline or ask for more time to research. There will always be other trading opportunities. Rushing into a trade without due diligence can result in losing out on valuable items or ending up with something you don't want.

This trader's regret serves as a humble reminder that successful trading in MM2 requires continuous learning and careful decision-making. Staying informed is your best defense against unfavorable trades.

Sources

More from Murder Mystery 2