All Murder Mystery 2 articles
Murder Mystery 2

MM2 Traders Eye Candleflame for Makeshift Swaps

Traders in Murder Mystery 2 are weighing swaps between Candleflame and Makeshift, highlighting ongoing market demand for Halloween godlies.

November 18, 2026 URV Editorial
Ultimate Roblox Values

Trading in Murder Mystery 2 often hinges on finding the right match between high-tier godlies, and recent community discussions highlight player interest in swapping Candleflame for Makeshift. As traders constantly adjust their inventories to secure their dream weapons, offers pitting seasonal godlies against each other remain at the center of MM2 trade lobbies.

A recent community post in the MM2 trading scene brought attention to a direct swap proposition: offering Candleflame in pursuit of Makeshift. Both items carry strong reputations in the secondary market, making this specific matchup a recurring topic of debate among active collectors.

Evaluating Candleflame and Makeshift

To understand how a deal like this plays out, it helps to look at where both weapons stand in the current trading landscape.

Candleflame

Introduced during the Halloween Event in 2021, Candleflame is an Ancient rarity weapon that quickly became a fan favorite. Known for its distinct flame aesthetic and unique animations, it has historically maintained solid demand. While its market trajectory has experienced fluctuations over various trading updates, it remains a premier godly item that many collectors seek out for set completions and aesthetic loadouts.

Makeshift

Makeshift, on the other hand, made its debut as part of the 2022 Halloween Event. As a crafted-style gun godly, it carries a rugged, post-apocalyptic appearance that appeals strongly to players looking for unique firearm skins. Because it arrived in a later seasonal update, its distribution and circulating supply differ somewhat from earlier releases, often influencing how prospective traders view its stability.

Market Dynamics: Even Swap or Uneven Deal?

When community members propose direct 1:1 trades between high-value weapons, several practical factors determine whether the exchange actually happens:

  • Demand Over Pure Numbers: While value lists provide numeric estimates, individual demand frequently dictates whether a trade goes through. A player who views Makeshift as their dream weapon might gladly trade away Candleflame, even if general market sentiment leans slightly toward one side.
  • Weapon Preference (Gun vs. Knife): Traders often specialize their inventories around specific weapon types. Makeshift satisfies those seeking an eye-catching gun skin, while Candleflame appeals to collectors prioritizing flashy ancient melee weapons.
  • Fluctuation Risks: High-tier Halloween items are subject to periodic market shifts. When trading older event items for newer ones, participants generally weigh long-term stability against short-term hype.

Takeaways for MM2 Traders

For players holding either weapon, direct swaps can be an effective way to acquire target items without involving complex adds or multiple small godlies. However, successful negotiation typically requires checking up-to-date trading values right before hitting accept. If you are pursuing a specific dream skin like Makeshift, offering an established item like Candleflame gives you strong leverage, but being open to minor value adjustments can help finalize the deal faster.

Sources

More from Murder Mystery 2