All Murder Mystery 2 articles
Murder Mystery 2

Elitey Pet in Murder Mystery 2: A Trading Misconception?

A recent post on the Murder Mystery 2 subreddit highlighted a common point of confusion for traders regarding the Elitey pet. Many players believe it to be worthless, but is that truly the case?

June 6, 2026 URV Editorial

Confusion is brewing in the Murder Mystery 2 trading community, particularly around the value of the Elitey pet. A recent Reddit post from a player who inherited an Elitey pet from their brother sparked discussion, as they were repeatedly told the pet was "worthless and useless" when attempting to trade it.

This sentiment isn't uncommon for certain items in MM2, especially those that might have been part of older events or bundles that are no longer easily obtainable. The Elitey pet, while not a highly sought-after godly or ancient, still holds a place in the game's history and collection.

Understanding Pet Values in MM2

In Murder Mystery 2, an item's value is often determined by several factors:

Rarity

How difficult is the item to acquire? Limited-time event items, especially those from years past, naturally become rarer over time. However, rarity alone doesn't always guarantee high demand or value. Some rare items might simply not appeal to the broader player base.

Demand

This is perhaps the most crucial factor. Even if an item is rare, if no one wants it, its trade value will be minimal. Demand is driven by aesthetics, competitive advantages (though less common for pets), and its place in popular collections or sets.

Popularity of the Source Event/Bundle

Items from hugely popular events or paid bundles tend to retain more value, even if they aren't top-tier in terms of rarity. They represent a piece of MM2 history that many players want to collect.

The Elitey Pet's Place in the Market

The Elitey pet likely falls into a category of items that, while not incredibly common, also doesn't have sky-high demand. Players new to trading or those unfamiliar with older items might genuinely believe it has no value because it isn't frequently traded or listed for high-tier items. However, "worthless" is a strong word and usually an exaggeration.

For traders, understanding these nuances is key. An Elitey pet might not fetch a godly knife, but it could certainly be a valuable addition to a smaller trade, or for a collector seeking to complete their pet collection. Its value fluctuates, often being more appealing to niche collectors rather than mainstream traders looking for quick profit.

Takeaways for Traders

  • Do your research: Before dismissing an item as "worthless," check community forums, trade value lists, and past trades if possible. Some items have a small, dedicated collector base.
  • Target your audience: If you have an item like the Elitey pet, try to find traders who are specifically looking for pet collections or older, less common items.
  • Don't expect miracles: While an item might have some value, temper your expectations. Not everything will trade for a top-tier item.
  • Consider its age: Older items can sometimes hold sentimental value for long-time players, which can contribute to their tradeability, even if not for high-tier items.

The Elitey pet isn't worthless, but its value and demand are certainly different from the highly sought-after items in Murder Mystery 2. Knowing the factors that influence item value will help you navigate the trading landscape more effectively.

Sources

More from Murder Mystery 2